Gifted vs Paid: Why Gifted Performs Significantly Better

In the realm of influencer marketing, the decision between opting for gifted or paid partnerships is pivotal. While both strategies hold their value, there’s growing evidence that gifted collaborations might edge out paid ones in several key areas.

Let’s delve into the reasons why gifted influencer marketing often outperforms its paid counterpart, especially for brands looking to build authentic relationships and achieve long-term engagement.

Gifted Influencer Marketing

Gifted influencer marketing involves brands sending products or services to influencers as gifts, without a contractual obligation for the influencer to post about them. This strategy is particularly effective with nano and micro-influencers, who tend to have a closer, more personal connection with their audience. The benefits of gifted influencer marketing are compelling:

  • Authentic Engagement: Gifted collaborations foster genuine experiences and reactions from influencers. This authenticity translates into more relatable and trustworthy content for their followers, driving higher engagement rates compared to paid posts.
  • Cost-Effectiveness: For startups and small businesses, budget is often a constraint. Gifted collaborations offer a way to generate buzz and content without the hefty price tag associated with paid ads or high-profile influencer partnerships.
  • Organic Reach: By partnering with nano and micro-influencers through gifted collaborations, brands can tap into a vast network of engaged followers. These influencers, who often boast a market share of 91%, can significantly amplify a brand’s visibility in a more organic and credible manner.

Paid Collaborations

Paid collaborations, on the other hand, involve a financial agreement between the brand and the influencer, with specified deliverables, including posts or mentions. While this approach guarantees exposure and allows for creative control, it doesn’t always equate to better performance:

  • Lack of Authenticity: Paid posts are typically marked as ads, which can deter engagement from followers who prefer organic content. This perceived lack of authenticity might reduce the effectiveness of the message.
  • Higher Costs: Paid collaborations, especially with macro-influencers, come with significant costs. For brands with limited marketing budgets, these expenses can be prohibitive, making gifted collaborations a more viable option.
  • Quality vs. Quantity: While paid partnerships can ensure a post, they don’t guarantee that the influencer’s audience will engage with the content. Gifted collaborations often result in content that feels more personal and engaging, leading to better overall performance.

Why Gifted Performs Significantly Better

Gifted influencer marketing stands out for its ability to generate authentic, engaging content that resonates with audiences. In an online world cluttered with advertisements, the authenticity and personal touch of gifted collaborations can cut through the noise, building genuine connections and fostering trust with potential customers.

Moreover, the cost-effectiveness of gifted collaborations allows brands to allocate resources more efficiently, achieving better ROI and cultivating relationships with a wider range of influencers.


While both gifted and paid influencer marketing strategies have their merits, gifted collaborations offer unique advantages that can lead to significantly better performance in terms of engagement, authenticity, and cost-efficiency. For brands aiming to forge real connections and achieve sustainable growth, gifted influencer marketing presents a compelling pathway.

At BarkSocial, we specialize in crafting bespoke influencer marketing strategies that harness the power of authentic connections. Whether you’re looking to explore gifted collaborations or integrate a mix of gifted and paid partnerships, our team can guide you through optimizing your approach for maximum impact.

Elevate your brand with BarkSocial’s expert influencer marketing strategies and discover the difference authentic, gifted collaborations can make in your digital marketing success.

Get in Touch

Whether you have a question about our influencer marketing activity or would like to learn more about our services, we’d be happy to hear from you.
Use the contact form below to send us a message or call us directly on 0207 183 1022.